During investigations, credibility and reliability are often discussed together. Both are important when assessing witness evidence, but they address different questions. Understanding the distinction helps HR professionals and Investigators reach findings that are fair, evidence-based and capable of being explained.
An employee may provide an account that appears credible and genuinely believes their recollection is accurate. However, the information may still contain errors, omissions or assumptions. Equally, an account that initially appears inconsistent may contain reliable information when examined against contemporaneous records or other evidence. The investigator’s task is not simply to decide whom to believe. It is to examine what each account establishes, test it against the available evidence and explain the reasoning behind the findings.
What Is the Difference Between Credibility and Reliability?
Credibility concerns whether an account or witness is believable. It involves considering whether the information appears honest and whether there are reasonable grounds to accept the person’s account.
Relevant considerations may include internal consistency, the witness’s explanation of events, whether they distinguish personal knowledge from assumptions, and whether their account is consistent with other facts. Often, lengthy descriptions of emotional statements, with little or no recollection of surrounding details such as what happened immediately prior to the incident, who was present, what was said, etc can call credibility into question. Credibility is also questioned when the statement is in contrast to the evidence available, presented as a subset of the whole story, or contradicted by other credible sources. This article further talks about how credibility may be assessed.
Reliability concerns how accurately and dependably the information reflects what happened. A witness may be entirely honest but mistaken about a date, the words used in a conversation or the sequence of events. Reliability therefore requires consideration of the witness’s opportunity to observe, the passage of time, the quality of their recollection and any available corroborating evidence.
The two concepts overlap, but they are not interchangeable. An investigator should not assume that an honest witness necessarily provides an accurate account, or that an inconsistency automatically means someone is being dishonest.
The Australian Public Service Commission’s Handling Misconduct: A Human Resource Managers’ Guide discusses both credibility and reliability as separate considerations in assessing evidence. Its guidance is a useful professional reference for investigators, although its specific procedural requirements concern the Australian Public Service rather than every private-sector workplace.
How Credibility Is Assessed in Practice
Credibility is assessed through the evidence, not through personal impressions alone.
During an interview, an investigator notes whether a witness answers questions directly, acknowledges gaps in their memory and explains apparent inconsistencies. These observations can inform further questioning, but they should not determine the outcome in isolation.
For example, an employee alleges that their manager repeatedly made humiliating comments during team meetings. The employee provides a long statement of impact, and recalls in general terms what happened. While it is reasonable for people not to remember exact details of the words used, recollection of supporting information such as what happened immediately prior, or after the meeting, was there a witness, follow up email or text message, was there previous history linked to the conversation, etc can offer important information to the Investigator that help establish credibility. During one such interview, the complainant offered the full transcript of teams messages between him and the respondent on a particular day. During the response interview, the respondent referred to the same transcript, but only presented a subset of it, and denied knowledge of the broader exchange. This example called the respondent’s credibility into question.
In another scenario, a long, 6 page complaint that contained lengthy assertions of bullying were found to be based on a single interaction. The interaction wasn’t pleasant, and the respondent’s behaviour was not appropriate, however the complainant’s credibility got called into question because of overstating the incident and impact. Notably, if this situation applied to a harassment complaint, the Investigator’s assessment would change dramatically – because harassment doesn’t need to establish repetitive behaviour.
In a third example, an employee provides a detailed account of two incidents but is uncertain about the date of a third. Or in another case where various parties recall words or the sequence of events slightly differently. That uncertainty or lack of consistency does not necessarily undermine the events. The investigator needs to establish which details are central to the allegation, clarify what the employee remembers and identify whether other evidence can help establish the relevant events. Such matters do not undermine credibility, they are likely a result of partial recollections.
It is also important not to mistake presentation for truthfulness. A witness may appear confident but be mistaken. Another may be hesitant because the subject is uncomfortable or because they are concerned about workplace consequences.
Eye contact, visible emotion, composure and confidence are not dependable substitutes for evidence. Specialist investigators recognise the risk of allowing personal expectations or unconscious bias to influence credibility assessments.
Credibility is undoubtedly nuanced and requires good observation skills, ability to explore the details and an experienced investigator.
Reliability: Testing What the Evidence Can Establish
Reliability requires the investigator to look beyond whether an account sounds convincing.
Useful questions include:
- Did the witness personally observe the event, or are they repeating what another person told them?
- How soon after the event was the account recorded?
- Was the witness in a position to see or hear what they describe?
- Are there contemporaneous emails, messages, meeting notes, rosters or access records that support or contradict the account?
- Has the witness’s recollection changed, and can the difference reasonably be explained?
- Does independent evidence support a particular detail, or does it establish something more limited?
Contemporaneous records can be particularly useful because they were created closer to the event. However, their value depends on what they actually record.
Consider an employee who says they reported inappropriate conduct to a colleague immediately after a meeting. A message sent that afternoon referring to the incident may support the employee’s evidence that they raised a concern at the time. It does not necessarily establish every detail of the alleged conduct.
Similarly, a calendar entry may confirm that two employees attended the same meeting, but it does not prove what was said during it.
The investigator must distinguish between evidence that establishes an event occurred, evidence that supports a particular account and evidence that provides background only.
The Australian Public Service Commission’s guidance recommends examining primary sources, testing disputed facts and considering whether evidence can be verified independently. These are practical principles that can inform workplace investigations beyond the public sector.
When Witness Recollections Vary
Conflicting accounts are common in workplace investigations. Two employees may remember the same conversation differently, disagree about the tone of an exchange or have different recollections of what happened before an incident.
The existence of a disagreement does not establish that either person is lying.
An investigator should identify the precise points of disagreement and assess their significance. A minor difference about the time of a meeting may have little bearing on the central allegation. A fundamental disagreement about whether a conversation occurred may require closer examination.
Where appropriate, further questions should be put to the witnesses, relevant documents reviewed and additional witnesses identified. If new or adverse information emerges, the person affected should receive a fair opportunity to respond in accordance with the applicable process.
Hearsay evidence also requires careful treatment. A colleague who personally heard an alleged comment provides different evidence from someone who was told about it afterwards. The second account may help establish impact, and that a disclosure was made at a particular time, but it does not independently establish the truth of the underlying allegation.
The distinction is important where there are no direct witnesses. The absence of corroboration does not automatically mean an allegation cannot be substantiated. The available evidence must be assessed as a whole.
Why Specialist Investigation Expertise Matters
Workplace investigations require more than collecting statements and summarising competing versions of events. Investigators must develop relevant lines of inquiry, ask questions that test the evidence and recognise the limits of what can reasonably be established.
Specialist expertise is particularly useful where allegations are serious, evidence is largely circumstantial, witness accounts conflict or senior employees may influence the process.
An experienced investigator should be able to explain why particular evidence was accepted, given limited weight or rejected. They should also identify gaps that cannot be resolved and avoid filling those gaps with assumptions.
Independence can help manage actual or perceived conflicts of interest, but appointing an external investigator does not automatically make an investigation sound. The quality of the work still depends on the scope, evidence-gathering methods, interview approach, procedural fairness and analysis.
The investigator should remain within the terms of reference, pursue relevant evidence from all sides and maintain a clear record of the steps taken. They should not start with a preferred outcome and work backwards to justify it.
From Evidence Assessment to Defensible Findings
In Australian workplace investigations, the applicable standard of proof will depend on the context. The balance of probabilities is commonly used for workplace misconduct findings. In practical terms, the question is whether the allegation is more likely than not to have occurred, having assessed the evidence appropriately.
In Briginshaw v Briginshaw (1938) 60 CLR 336, the High Court discussed the care required when reaching reasonable satisfaction about facts, taking account of matters such as the seriousness of an allegation and the consequences of a finding. The decision does not establish a separate, higher standard of proof for serious workplace allegations.
A sound investigation report should set out the allegation, summarise the relevant evidence, address material inconsistencies and explain why the evidence supports the finding reached. Evidence that challenges the allegation should receive genuine consideration, not simply a passing reference.
Where the evidence is insufficient, the report should explain that limitation. A finding that an allegation is not substantiated does not necessarily mean it was false; it means the evidence did not establish it to the required standard.
The Investigator’s Role: Careful Assessment, Not Assumption
Credibility and reliability are complementary parts of evidence assessment. Credibility helps an investigator consider whether an account should be accepted. Reliability helps determine how accurately the information establishes the facts in question.
Neither should be assessed in isolation. The investigator must consider the whole body of evidence, test competing explanations, provide a fair opportunity to respond and explain the reasoning behind each finding.
For HR teams, this distinction is practical rather than merely technical. It helps prevent honest mistakes from being treated as dishonesty, confident accounts from being accepted without scrutiny and incomplete evidence from being overstated.
At Central HR, specialist investigation expertise can help organisations approach complex workplace matters through structured evidence gathering, impartial assessment, and clear reporting.
When witness accounts conflict, how does your organisation ensure it assesses credibility fairly and tests reliability against the available evidence?
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the difference between credibility and reliability in workplace investigations?
Credibility concerns whether a statement is believable. Reliability concerns how accurately the information reflects what happened. A witness may be honest but mistaken, so both aspects must be assessed.
Can a witness be credible but unreliable?
Yes. A witness may sincerely believe their recollection is accurate but misremember a date, conversation or sequence of events. Investigators should assess the account against other evidence where available.
How do investigators assess witness credibility?
Investigators consider the facts surrounding statements and test whether the recollections are simply vague or inflated and not likely to present the whole truth. Demeanour and presentation should not determine credibility.
How can investigators test the reliability of evidence?
They can examine contemporaneous records, seek independent corroboration, distinguish firsthand evidence from hearsay, clarify inconsistencies and consider the witness’s opportunity to observe and remember the events.
Why use a specialist workplace investigator?
A specialist can help structure the investigation, test competing accounts, identify relevant evidence, manage conflicts of interest and document a reasoned basis for findings. Specialist appointment does not remove the need for procedural fairness or sound evidence assessment.
Can a workplace allegation be substantiated without corroborating witnesses?
Yes. Independent corroboration is not always necessary. The investigator must assess all available evidence against the applicable standard of proof and explain why it supports, or does not support, the allegation.